No one is seeing it as a personal attack, we're discussing it's lore validity and how much people would want to interact with said person.
In all honesty, is there a reason why you can't go with a girl who has Amnesia? Or, if that's too normal for you, someone who was stuck in the void for a thousand years from Ampador and knows nothing about the new world? Or someone from Doma who knows nothing about Eorzea? Why a God? Why an EARTHEN God? You'd get the same results with a more lore compliant character.
In all honesty, is there a reason why you can't go with a girl who has Amnesia? Or, if that's too normal for you, someone who was stuck in the void for a thousand years from Ampador and knows nothing about the new world? Or someone from Doma who knows nothing about Eorzea? Why a God? Why an EARTHEN God? You'd get the same results with a more lore compliant character.