That is your opinion on things, not facts. Others have put down evidence on why those solutions are unlikely to work. I've put down my own reasons why Balmung won't reopen anytime soon.
Your argument boils down to not believing that smaller RP communities can offer the same experience as Balmung. Do we want to RP? Yes. Is there RP to be found elsewhere? Yes. Is this the perfect opportunity to create a second healthy community? Very yes.Â
But we don't have to be the same as Balmung's community. We don't have to be as big. And if Balmung lost half of it's RPers it would still be flourishing.
The RPC alone has over 10,000 accounts. If even a tenth of them were connected to another server it would be more than successful it would be flourishing. That doesn't include the other players that don't touch the forum.
And having a second server that isn't connected to whatever SE designates as official is good as well, because of everyone moved to the new server it would already be locked as well if RPC account numbers are even half accurate.