Is your character an incarnation or "port" from another game or universe? Perhaps an OC you utilize everywhere, same name, same characteristics, similar classes/jobs/roles every instance.
Do you retain memories and experiences? Maybe alter them in order to have them suit the character in the new world you've brought them into? Or do you simply take their core and start them with a clean slate? What about special lore or characteristics you've had for them that you wish to retain?
Or are they actually a traveler from another realm? Lightning's Event basically indicates that such a thing exists, and Dissidia is Universe cannon as well, which lends that as a transitional area between worlds.
Post, explain, go~
I know that FFXIV has, unfortunately, made traveling between worlds canon... But I gotta say, I'm not really a fan of it. It will never not seem Sue-ish to me. The furthest I have/will take it is travel to the Void. :<
Not a fan of this, personally. It's hardly ever done in a way that isn't corny a la Beastmaster II: Through the Portal of Time, but sadly the precedent is set with Lightning and Shantotto.
Right, so, T'rahnu is a character template I use in pretty much every game that has character creation. She's kind of my test for how powerful that character creation is.
She's always short but well-built, with more muscle mass and definition than you'd expect from a woman, with an androgynous build, short-cropped hair, and the same yellow-tan+black hair+brown eyes color combination. Unsurprisingly, it is REALLY HARD to find games that actually let me recreate her accurately (muscle slider in particular is shockingly absent for reasons that are beyond me). Most games seem to focus on idealized women so making a completely androgynous one is basically impossible.
Her personality, on the other hand, varies depending on the game world and what I feel is appropriate at the time. Her Aion incarnation, for example, is a super-hardassed centuries old warrior (which, contrasted with her appearance, makes her stand out quite a bit IMO). Her EVE incarnation is a suave high-class businesswoman. Her PSO2 incarnation is basically a hot-blooded superheroine. And her FFXIV incarnation is that of a skilled and multi-talented but lonely wanderer who maintains a facade of cheerfulness wherever she goes.
There's a number of games that I've played where I don't make her at all, because the options simply aren't there. In that case I fall back to one of my other recurring character templates,
Aiza, who is also sort of a test in terms of mixing the cute factor with the creepy factor, which again is something only so many games can manage.
Well, it's not as if the Lightning event was done in an awesome way either. Some people treat those as OOC styled events though as outside of their occurrence they don't seem to affect anything in the world.
People are free to RP whatever makes them happiest.
That said, I kind of agree with Faye. If you're RPing in FFXIV, why not make a character that belongs in FFXIV? It's not hard to make a copy of the character you love with similar characteristics, backstory, etc.
I also personally feel like if you 100% MUST have character that's traveled from a different world to be happy, it makes a lot of sense for to:
1) Have your character keep it a secret, so no one IC-wise thinks you're crazy and/or tries to exploit them. Why would your world traveler straight up tell people they're from a different world? It's a fast track to having others around you think you've gone mad. Lightning had giant terrifying world-hopping monsters to back up her claims and Shanttoto is... well... she's Shanttoto. It makes much more sense for them to wait until they find people they trust and confide in them. Plus, it could be fun to think up a cover-story for your character on who they are and where they've been.
2) Not have special super powers that are completely impossible for normal folks to have in the land of Eorzea (like spending an hour powering up their chi only to have their hair turn blonde and spikey while they fly through the air.) OR just have them be stuff that everybody around you can easily explain away as magic/technology/etc. This is honestly just to make it easier for folks to accept your dimension-hopper and not see them as a god-moding, OP, mary-sue that shatters immersion with a single Kamehameha.
I often have a female character named after my username (Zetchryn) which I do everywhere that shares certain physical characteristics throughout all the games, but her personality and history is never set in stone. She's always sort of my 'test drive' character, the one I first explore a world with. I do it partially so if anyone calls my name in game, I INSTANTLY see it as I'm used to it, rather then getting so lost in the world that I don't notice that my new moniker's been being called for a time.
History is always tailored to the world, as well as personality.
Herp - I forgot to mention. I basically reuse the heck out of names, because I am super awful at naming characters. There is a "Lurial" and a "Tiergan" in nearly every game I play - but they don't often share the same characteristics because I build them based off of the game I'm playing. (Though FFXIV Tiergan and SWTOR Tiergan were both slaves. :V) They generally have different personalities and the only thing that's similar is the name.
And maybe the fact that Lurial usually has white hair. :V
Leilani Leilai is also based off of my old tarutaru character from FFXI with the same name and roughly the same appearance - but they're not the same person.
Aysun is a name/character I have used in multiple places now, though this is the only second time I have RP'd her. Her basic personality starts off about the same, however the universe she is set in and the interaction she has shapes her. I do not carry over any previous RP/plots/background, modified or not. This Aysun is very different emotionally and psychologically from the original I made due to the XIV universe she is in and the RP I've had with her.
Visually, the heterochromia, petite/scrappiness, and tendency for short hair carries over.
The only reference to prior MMO games and RP characters is the name of a ship. The Midnight Kestrel was the vessel that Steel's mother, Eyriswerd Keltkhan, used to captain before becoming part of the thalassocracy. The Midnight Kestrel was also the name of my main character in City of Heroes, who was an Arch/NRG Blaster. :3
Other than that, Steel is a completely unique creation. Didn't seem right that she'd be a carry-over from any other universe...but I couldn't help but make that little reference.
There's always a Banquo for me, as he means a lot to me after this long writing him, but I prefer to think of it not so much as the same individual finding himself landing in whatever fresh circumstances have to be available (which is all the better for him, given his grumpy general distrust of magic like an old man puzzling over a smartphone).
Each one ultimately strives towards the same (near-impossible) goal using the means available to them in a given world or setting, and some of them fail, and some of them succeed, depending on how far they get and what resources they can reach. To me, it feels more like separate iterations based on the same original plan, but they always end up way different from each other by the conclusion of their journey, because of the different challenges they've dealt with and people they've met. In that way, I guess it's sort of an experiment in adapting a character to suit new circumstances?
I do often reuse characters' personalities and occasionally names if they fit the lore, but rather than have them arrive in the world via portal/interdimensionary travel/the Magic School Bus, I create a similar character that fits the game world. Yvelont is heavily modeled after an old MUD/D&D character of mine. He also has an incarnation in World of Warcraft and in Lord of the Rings Online, albeit with different names that fit their settings.
In LOTRO, he's Celothor Gildorion and in WoW he's Teveriel!
And then there's the original, created in '96. This is what we had for screenshots back then:
You see Master Teveriel Anduin Vaalor the Paladin of Voln.
He appears to be an Elf.
He is tall and appears to be mature. He has brooding steel grey eyes and fair skin. He has shoulder length, straight silver blonde hair swept back from the temples. He has an angular face and broad shoulders.
He is in good shape.
He is holding a heavy steel bastard sword with a hilt wrapped in vruul hide in his right hand.
He is wearing a somber black hooded longcloak, a white-enameled villswood greatshield slung over his shoulder, a full suit of brightly polished steel platemail, an ebon-veined white marble band, a silver-studded black leather belt, an antiquated black lacquered scabbard, a drawstring gem pouch, a pair of reinforced black leather trousers, and some heavy black leather boots.
(All actual "worn" gear, not a written description. Man, that's a lotta black.)
Because I'm sure to piss someone off by saying it, I'll prepend the caveat that I'm not making any value judgements about anyone else's RP. This is just me.
That said, I never understood the "This character is the same one I played in Tera/Wow/Eve Online/Minecraft/Tetris" thing, and so I've never done it. I adore learning about the lore of a world, so I love making fresh characters that wholly inhabit it. For alts, I sometimes use elements of old characters (for instance, Meleia in EQ2 was a Freeport Chekist and spy for the Overlord; Gehmor in Star Trek Online was a Cardassian trained as an intelligence officer before the fall of Cardassia; Armistead Moreau is a Duskwight who lived in a large Clan and was employed as a spy before the Calamity devastated them), but that's about it. Names, cultures, backgrounds, etc, all get created whole cloth.
I don't like IC universe porting either.
OOCly, however, Oli's general job and personality has roots in other places, starting with the personality of my Asura from GW2, coupled with the knowledge-gathering job of my Sylvari (also from GW2). His concept then enjoyed some baking time as a She in a superhero MMO as a dimension-traveling scientist. A slightly more comedic version of his concept then surfaced as, well, Himself, in this game.
It's been a loooong trip!
...Now that I look at it, all of these steps seem completely unrelated. But trust me, they're connected. Somehow.
If anyone recognize the last name "Deneith" for my character Roen, it is because it is the name of one of the Dragonmarked Houses from Eberron Campaign setting.
Roen Deneith's first incarnation was in a 3.5e D&D campaign. That campaign ended after five years and I fell in love with the character that I've come to learn inside and out.
So when I discovered FF, I created her again, with an idea of "What if this character was born in another world under entirely different circumstances... how would she turn out?"
So she is not actually a reincarnation, or even the same character. I just reused the name and the person she is at the core. But I am leaving who she becomes and how the circumstances change her to RP and storytelling, which so far, as had some significant divergence from the D&D campaign, as well as some eerie similarities, oddly enough.
Brynn I have also used in other forums and settings, always a horse trader and a dance loving gypsy with a selfish streak about her. I use her as a side character to stories, and in this game she is an alt of mine to support people's arcs as well. She also lets me be a shameless flirt.
