+- Hydaelyn Role-Players (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18)
+-- Forum: Final Fantasy 14 (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18/forumdisplay.php?fid=41)
+--- Forum: FFXIV Discussion (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18/forumdisplay.php?fid=12)
+--- Thread: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) (/showthread.php?tid=11044)
Pages:
1
2
Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Anstarra - 04-10-2015
So. All that happened.
Right now, those of us done with the MSQ are able to walk around and talk to NPCs and things seem to be kinda covered-up or hush-hush. Like when we talk to the Paladin trainer and he speaks of
And yet, if we recall the whole banquet that was happening and that got so dramatically interrupted, there were MANY 'nameless people' in attendance. People of import, no doubt, probably rich merchants, Monetarists, Royalists. Folks with connections, and import, in their own purview.
With this in mind, how long can we REALLY expect to believe that the grand crime will remain a secret? Even if the true author of it remains muddled, THAT SIMPLE FACT was made (loudly) crystal clear before an audience of at least dozens of the city's luminaries. They gasped, they were shocked, etc etc.
There is no single way in hell none of these people are going to spread that story around. Even if it was on pain of death - and let's face it, the Monetarists have no real incentive to hush it that tightly - PEOPLE WILL TALK.
I'm not saying it's already happened, but I think pretty soon it would come out. Thus, my question. How long is long enough, for us to wait until word on the street is out? I'm not saying the WHOLE TRUTH will ever be out... but to know about the murder? THAT should already be common knowledge, if you ask me. It's farcical to imagine no one who was there would talk. Like, 'So Bob, you were there, why the heck did Raubahn flip his shit?' 'Oh, Sam, WELL he was just told that-' I mean come on.
I don't know if this' been addressed in another threat comprehensively, if so I apologize! I'm just wondering how soon we can stop pretending to be blind, deaf and dumb. Maybe within like a month? To allow most players to pass the MSQ?
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Kellach Woods - 04-10-2015
You can be sure that anyone who was in there is either shutting up, in jail or a target of Lolorito's cadre of assassins.
I'm honestly surprised Ul'dah isn't just littered with corpses.
Y'know, just the kind of thing that someone who's unscrupulous and access to the TRADER'S SPURN would love.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - McBeefâ„¢ - 04-10-2015
You have not considered the alternative.
What if Nanamo really is recovering from the poisoning? As far as I remember, the Warrior of Light never gets to check the body.
Lolorito was careful to detach himself from the deed, using Teledji as an intermediary. He might have done this just to force all of Nanamo's allies out of the city, so he can rule, with Nanamo as his puppet.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - K'nahli - 04-10-2015
Until the next patch comes out and explains such a timeline for you. Or so would be my philosophy.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Kellach Woods - 04-10-2015
Next patch is pre-3.0 event.
I sincerely doubt we'll be revisiting Ul'dah.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Melkire - 04-10-2015
Think we've had a number of topics on 2.55 you could sift through for opinions, though we're open to another, I'm sure. Uhhhh... links... links...
http://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/showthread.php?tid=10890
http://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/showthread.php?tid=10902
http://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/showthread.php?tid=10893
http://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/showthread.php?tid=10892
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - K'nahli - 04-10-2015
(04-10-2015, 07:24 PM)Kellach Woods Wrote: Next patch is pre-3.0 event.
I sincerely doubt we'll be revisiting Ul'dah.
You don't need to revisit Ul'dah to have information fed to you about what is currently taking place. I'll be very surprised if it's 100% about Ishgard and we don't hear so much as a peep from the other nations' leaders nor a bunch of comments along the lines of:
"The citizens are growing increasingly restless with all of the rumours flying around. A great majority are already of a stout opinion that there is more going on than a mere 'illness' ".
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Enla - 04-10-2015
(04-10-2015, 07:15 PM)Natalie Mcbeef Wrote: You have not considered the alternative.
What if Nanamo really is recovering from the poisoning? As far as I remember, the Warrior of Light never gets to check the body.
Lolorito was careful to detach himself from the deed, using Teledji as an intermediary. He might have done this just to force all of Nanamo's allies out of the city, so he can rule, with Nanamo as his puppet.
That and there are poisons that do mimic death, tricking all by the best in medical technology that we have at our disposal. I wouldn't be surprised if Eorzea had some equivalent of the puffer fish poison.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Chris Ganale - 04-10-2015
Eorzea has puffer fish if I remember my fishing log correctly.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Enla - 04-10-2015
(04-10-2015, 08:01 PM)Chris Ganale Wrote: Eorzea has puffer fish if I remember my fishing log correctly.
Question is, is it the kind with the similar poison that literally can trick people into thinking whomever ingested it has passed on. Still, the fact that it IS in there does make me lean more to the idea that Nanamo might very well be alive. Thanks for pointing that out.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Chris Ganale - 04-10-2015
I'd have to switch characters to check my fishing log, but I want to say that the Eorzean puffer fish is supposed to be an out-and-out expy of the Japanese one that murders people just for looking at its flesh funny.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Sounsyy - 04-10-2015
(04-10-2015, 08:04 PM)Cylin Wrote:(04-10-2015, 08:01 PM)Chris Ganale Wrote: Eorzea has puffer fish if I remember my fishing log correctly.
Question is, is it the kind with the similar poison that literally can trick people into thinking whomever ingested it has passed on. Still, the fact that it IS in there does make me lean more to the idea that Nanamo might very well be alive. Thanks for pointing that out.
Quote:Blowfish
A saltwater fish that, when provoked, blows up to three times its normal size to intimidate the would-be attacker. It is also known to have an organ which contains a potent silencing poison.
Quote:Weak Silencing Potion
An unstable concoction which induces temporary loss of voice.
Ingredients: Blowfish, Quicksilver, Bat Wing
So no, puffer fish in Eorzea wouldn't have that death-like affect on Nanamo.
Morbols and Belladonna on the other hand... (I've used a similar concoction as a sedative for intubation/surgery in an RP before.)
Quote:Sleeping Potion
A concoction which instantly induces deep slumber.
Ingredients: Morbol Vine, Belladonna, Quicksilver
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Yssen - 04-10-2015
It is not covered up. Well. While we can tell from NPC dialogue that people in Ul'dah are trying to suppress what happened, dialogue out side of Ul'dah says tells us it is not working well. Both Baderon and Miunne know what happened, and more than a few other NPCs also talk about knowing what is up. While the full details are probably shrouded in a haze of misinformation generating from Uldy, not everyone is buying it. The NPCs are talking, and the Syndicate is not strong enough to suppress people not in Ul'dah.
I do not think the misinformation and silence on the part of Uldy is to prevent people outside the city-state from knowing the truth or talking. The NPCs are putting out a story to prevent the situation from getting worse. They know what happened, but the streets would run red with blood if someone with authority confirmed it publicly. It prevents further chaos. To be fair, the conspiracy is not concerned with what people in other nations know. The other nations cannot act with out basically going to war with Ul'dah.
My personal prediction, Uldy is being Black Wolfed like Ala Mhigo. Someone (or someones) on the Syndicate is allied with the Empire. Chaos is being spread and a powder keg primed for eventual Garlean takeover. Random details in spoilery tag.Â
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Chris Ganale - 04-10-2015
I'm still convinced that it was an utter failure of sound military judgment not to seize and hold Castrum Meridianum when we had crippled it, demolished its garrison, and decapitated its leadership. If that is not the prime opportunity to raise the Eorzean flag from the parapets, then I don't know what is.
RE: Consensus on the Conspiracy of Silence? (2.55-related, beware Spoilers) - Yssen - 04-10-2015
Sound military judgement? Yes. Sound political judgement? Maaaybe not so much.