+- Hydaelyn Role-Players (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18)
+-- Forum: Final Fantasy 14 (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18/forumdisplay.php?fid=41)
+--- Forum: FFXIV Discussion (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18/forumdisplay.php?fid=12)
+--- Thread: Balmung Restriction Discussion (/showthread.php?tid=9805)
Balmung Restriction Discussion - Y'lani - 01-26-2015
If you want to talk about the restrictions of Balmung, whether it's asking what are the best ways to approach it, confiding in others because it's fairly difficult to get in, or just talking about it, post here instead of here!
Why make this thread? It ensures that new players are not discouraged when they see somebody posting in the "Balmung is open!" thread only to see that Balmung is not open.
Feel free to discuss!
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - WolfyRipper - 01-26-2015
Good thread to have. I think the character restriction is just total garbage, to be honest. I understand trying to halt the masses...but in reality. If I have a character -on- Balmung already and I just want to make a new one...I should be able to without restriction.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Telluride - 01-26-2015
As long as the restriction fails to keep out the bots - and it is failing at this quite thoroughly - I find it to be a poor solution to whatever SE thinks the problem actually is.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - FreelanceWizard - 01-26-2015
As I've said before, they really need to fix this before the expansion, with all the Au Ra alts that people are going to want to make (and the player pickup on an expansion release).
Frankly, at this point, I don't really see what their code is actually doing. Lobby server issues aside, at one point the devs noted that they didn't want to stress the newbie zones. That's fine -- but the newbie zones are almost entirely empty these days. If their logic is "look at number of level 1 characters on the server/in this zone" and isn't accounting for logged in characters, then that's a bug they need to fix. Beyond all that, though, they desperately need to upgrade their server infrastructure.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Khivva - 01-26-2015
The things I do for RP lol.Â
I've spent the past 2-3 days trying to sign up my character but there hasn't been a single opening. I thought ok, Saturday, everyone and their mother is on. Try Sunday people will have to go back to work. Nothing opened up last night/ this morning. I've read threads of people saying Tue-Thur is the best time but lol I don't know if I'm down to not sleep another night. I've really been considering just rolling my char in the server I have my main and that way be able to provide for her clothes or other small needs/ get her as high enough a level in three days and then transfer her over but 18 USD burns me along with the subscription.Â
I might just bite the bullet though because it's not worth how I'm feeling right now from not sleeping lol.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Warren Castille - 01-26-2015
(01-26-2015, 03:42 PM)wasurete Wrote: The things I do for RP lol.Â
I've spent the past 2-3 days trying to sign up my character but there hasn't been a single opening. I thought ok, Saturday, everyone and their mother is on. Try Sunday people will have to go back to work. Nothing opened up last night/ this morning. I've read threads of people saying Tue-Thur is the best time but lol I don't know if I'm down to not sleep another night. I've really been considering just rolling my char in the server I have my main and that way be able to provide for her clothes or other small needs/ get her as high enough a level in three days and then transfer her over but 18 USD burns me along with the subscription.Â
I might just bite the bullet thought because it's not worth how I'm feeling right now from not sleeping lol.
Never spend money when tired. That's how you end up missing a million gil and log in to new glamours.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Khivva - 01-26-2015
(01-26-2015, 03:42 PM)Warren Castille Wrote: Never spend money when tired. That's how you end up missing a million gil and log in to new glamours.
skdlfjslk xD You speak from experience?
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Aris - 01-26-2015
(01-26-2015, 03:42 PM)Warren Castille Wrote:(01-26-2015, 03:42 PM)wasurete Wrote: The things I do for RP lol.Â
I've spent the past 2-3 days trying to sign up my character but there hasn't been a single opening. I thought ok, Saturday, everyone and their mother is on. Try Sunday people will have to go back to work. Nothing opened up last night/ this morning. I've read threads of people saying Tue-Thur is the best time but lol I don't know if I'm down to not sleep another night. I've really been considering just rolling my char in the server I have my main and that way be able to provide for her clothes or other small needs/ get her as high enough a level in three days and then transfer her over but 18 USD burns me along with the subscription.Â
I might just bite the bullet thought because it's not worth how I'm feeling right now from not sleeping lol.
Never spend money when tired. That's how you end up missing a million gil and log in to new glamours.
Can confirm. Did this over the weekend.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Enzo - 01-26-2015
I am a bit contested on how SE does their servers. On one hand, I have played a LOT of MMORPGs. And while I have fairly nice internet and a fairly nice computer, I have always encountered some problems or a slight lag when playing the game at times. But with FFXIV? I encounter flawless servers that would probably keep me on the game even if my internet went out or something. I don't know how they keep such good connection while other even bigger games fail to. On the other hand, I think possibly the reason their servers run so well for me is because of them brutally hammering down on these server restrictions when they really don't need to. Their servers seem beyond perfect to me from what I have seen and moving from "Beyond perfect" to "Perfect" seems like a pretty nice trade off if it allows us to actually make new characters with who we want.
I agree with freelance in that starter zones are no longer an issue. And people rather quickly migrate away from them even now so that should not be their excuse. I think the kick off after a certain amount of time should be reinstated. Like 15 or 30 minutes if they are totally idle. I feel like I heard some complaints that servers were not as good when that was implemented before. But I think it was more server infrastructure that was lacking than it was the feature itself. I really don't see why they shouldn't have this feature when it works fine for every other MMORPG out there. It would really get rid of people just taking of space. Then the second problem is that of Bots. I have encountered games with varying levels of bot control. And admittedly I do not see bots very often on FFXIV. But I have heard lots of stories regarding bots to the point where I can imagine they are an issue. So that is something SE needs to solve.
Lastly I think they just need to upgrade their servers generally. I don't really know why they can't do this. Yeah it would cost money but they have a lot of players and wouldn't the gain in profits from allowing people to play with their friends make it all worth it in the end? I am no accountant. And I am sure there is a lot more in play here. But it is still making somewhat of a miserable situation for me as I don't have the money to transfer but want to make my new character on balmung. I am not getting up crazy early to meet ques or anything. But I naturally wake up at 6 am every day CST and have checked to see every server open except for Balmung. I have not been trying for very long (Since saturday) But I don't want to imagine becoming one of the horror stories of weeks and weeks without being able to get onto the server I want to play
I still don't really understand why Gilgamesh can be open, with a population 9/8ths bigger than Balmung and Balmung remain closed...
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Enla - 01-27-2015
The cynical part of me wonders if it's money related honestly, as in the past I've noted that roleplayers have a tendency to fork over cash a much steadier rate if it helps enable their hobby. I already put money down for the transfer fee to get Cylin over to Balmung, and would have put money down on Zahir'ra as well if my common sense hadn't kicked in and prevented me from porting a level one character over simply because I don't know when Balmung will ever be open. Or, honestly, if I'll ever be awake enough to see it happen.
However that just doesn't make sense in my mind at the end of the day, as not everyone who comes to Balmung is a roleplayer. So as a newbie looking in, I'm just as stumped as everyone else.
Frankly if it were server issues one big thing they could do is shorten the time it takes before you're kicked from the game from being AFK. I'm not even sure this IS a feature as while on Gilgamesh I once went questing in Thanalan and over the course of three to five hours went back and forth past a single player who neither moved or did anything, I'm assuming they were afk this whole time, and they weren't booted. The same happened today while in Ul'dah. Seems like the first way to alleviate server congestion is to kick off people who are AFK for more than an hour, I think even SWTOR has a thirty minute limit to move the camera at the very least before you're booted.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Kellach Woods - 01-27-2015
Roleplayers are also not a significant marketshare enough to even warrant such thought.
I'm thinking that Balmung's Legacy Server status also limits the new character creation much more harshly than Gilgamesh, if the population numbers are to be believed.
I wouldn't be surprised if, assuming the Legacy Server status actually does something to the lock, that it also introduced a bug that doesn't clear character creations from the queue, or does it abnormally, making it believe there's more than is actually created.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Parvacake - 01-27-2015
I've converted about four or five people to this game in the last month or two. I probably would have been able to get more (and thus more money for SE) if the server restriction didn't make it nearly impossible for some people due to their personal and/or work schedules.
I wish they brought back an afk timed kick. Maybe after half an hour or so. I have an FC member who will forget to log out when he goes to work and will be in the same spot for 6-8 hours undisturbed.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - allgivenover - 01-27-2015
(01-26-2015, 03:26 PM)FreelanceWizard Wrote: As I've said before, they really need to fix this before the expansion, with all the Au Ra alts that people are going to want to make (and the player pickup on an expansion release).
I... hadn't thought of how the Balmung restriction might will still be in effect come Heavensward and severely limit AuRa creation.Â
Best possibility I've read about AuRa and Heavensward in regard to RP in days, not even being sarcastic, I hope it stays locked.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - ReforgedWoodenSword - 01-27-2015
(01-27-2015, 10:13 AM)allgivenover Wrote:So...you're hoping new character creation stays locked throughout the release of the expansion...?(01-26-2015, 03:26 PM)FreelanceWizard Wrote: As I've said before, they really need to fix this before the expansion, with all the Au Ra alts that people are going to want to make (and the player pickup on an expansion release).
I... hadn't thought of how the Balmung restriction might will still be in effect come Heavensward and severely limit AuRa creation.Â
Best possibility I've read about AuRa and Heavensward in regard to RP in days, not even being sarcastic, I hope it stays locked.
RE: Balmung Restriction Discussion - Unnamed Mercenary - 01-27-2015
In regards to the expansion, hopefully they'll increase the limit of players allowed to login/be created if only because all the progression-based players will likely flock to Ishgard and any other new maps. (Think Wineport, Fallgourd and Ceruleum Processing Plant for people who did Coil with lockouts).Â
With the large increase in maps. if their servers are actually being taxed by the amount of players logged in, 3.0 would never be able ot make it past QA. They would -need- to upgrade their servers if that were the case.
I think their bottleneck (besides the Lobby Server) might actually be the internet connection and its backbone connections. We've seen alarming issues with the USA<->Canada border connections having issues. If they allowed more players in, these would likely get worse. disclaimer: enterprise networking of any kind is not my specialty. But when there's a collection of people who all run a trace route from their various locations and it fails at the same gateway.... it's suspicious. Perhaps the EU datacenter will help out with this. Maybe a decent portion of progression-based EU players will hop off Balmung to go enjoy a less-laggy gaming environment.