RPC has moved! These pages have been kept for historical purposes

Ha'uruh Nunh · **03-29-2015, 08:46 PM**

Japanese.Â I speak some, plus as it's the original, I feel the voice actors were chosen with the most precision and correct inflections, etc.

V'aleera · **03-29-2015, 09:16 PM**

http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/threa...ost2804270

This is one of the posts written to give insight into how the FFXIV localization team functions and the roles it performs, in case anyone cared to learn more about that.

Enla · **03-30-2015, 01:49 AM**

I've taste tested both Japanese and English tracks, and honestly I'm torn as to which I like better. I both love and despise voices on either end of the spectrum, and at the end of the day I only really went with English for two major reasons. First, it's my native tongue so I'm not trying to constantly read the subtitles while putting the words together in my head to see if anything is wrong with the translation. Secondly... I honestly prefer most of the Scions in English. Don't get me wrong, I don't think the voices are necessarily bad in Japanese nor do I really hate any of them with -one- exception. However some of the voices just... Didn't fit for me. Papalymo just did not sound right in Japanese for me given his personality, for example. The only one I dislike regardless of localization however, is Minfillia's voice choices. However that is probably a side affect of my hatred of the character and nothing more.

Marisa · **03-30-2015, 02:21 AM**

(03-29-2015, 08:46 PM)Ha Wrote: Japanese.Â I speak some, plus as it's the original, I feel the voice actors were chosen with the most precision and correct inflections, etc.

Now, I'll admit I'm only basing this off a panel I attended with Sonny Strait and his Japanese counterpart (they both did Maes Hughes in FMA, Sonny also did Krillin in DBZ and like a million other dub characters) but I have it on good authority that Japanese voice acting is just as much of a clusterfuck as it is in America. You have a handful of good voice actors who dominate the industry because they can do a wide range of voices really well, and everyone else is somewhere between decent and terrible. This is true for both Japan and America. And I honestly can't see the Japanese actors for XIV being any higher quality than the American ones, because they're being paid roughly the same. Â

Now, one big argument brought up alot in anime with 'subs vs dubs', is that the subs are better, not because the actors are better, but because they can be directly coached by the writer to sound how he originally intended. But... here's the secret. That never happens. That's not how it works on either end. Even in Japan, the voice actors come in to the studio, they sit alone in a sound booth with a script of their lines, and they read them off as quickly as possible. A sound director will sometimes be there to coach them, but that's true for the dub actors too. The writer, however, is in no way involved in this process. He's left them some notes in their script, but the Americans got those same notes.Â

In fact, here's the kicker with anime: The Americans get to watch the show before they dub it, because it's already been made. The Japanese teams are usually trying to record voices for an episode that hasn't even been animated yet. Though, to be fair, this doesn't apply to XIV. In XIV, neither the Japanese nor the Americans get to see any of these cutscenes before they record them. Â

Now, if you genuinely prefer the Japanese version, I have nothing against that. I promise I'm not trying to insult you in any way. I just want to be sure there are no illusions that the Japanese team somehow produces a superior product.

Faye · **03-30-2015, 02:36 PM**

(03-29-2015, 07:23 PM)Val Wrote: I, uh.

I don't watch the cutscenes.

Get out. GET OUT.

Caspar · **03-30-2015, 02:52 PM**

Just because they're paid the same doesn't mean their performance is of equal quality. Not that I watch the JP dub because I think the quality is better; that's subjective. The JP industry has a more established voice-acting base, whereas in the US, things have improved a great deal, but it's still seen as a lesser form of acting than live action, given that most are still failed live action or theater actors. This also doesn't mean they're poor quality actors, but an industry with lesser prestige is less likely to attract genuinely skilled performers.

I'm skeptical that the sound directors don't ever have a role in selecting specific VA and deliberating on which recorded session to use in the final cut. I've seen nothing to indicate this was the case. Maybe some studios are like that, but no matter how you slice it, the JP one is always working closer with the original creator. Even if they don't have him involved, they're a more seasoned production company that has been selecting VA and directing adaptations of scripts for decades. It just follows that usually their casting choice and direction are more likely to be superior to a second-hand production.

Tons of people fail in both the US and JP industry and only a select few get all the roles. That's true of any performance based industry. That doesn't make their quality of performance equitable. If anything, the studios in JP industry have noticed there is a surplus of people who want to become seiyuu compared to those who wish to become writers or animators, and have complained about it in various interviews. (Whether that's true or not or they're trying to deflect attention from their terrible hours and payment of their own employees is debatable.)

But again it's sort of subjective. If 'more accurate to the original concept' is the superior performance, then I'd say it's inarguable that the sub is superior in all cases. If 'you enjoy it more' is the superior performance, that's subjective. In any case, I picked up sub personally not because I felt it was superior, but because I feel it invalidates the work of the original intended cast and the creator to not watch the work as close to how it was intended as possible.

allgivenover · **03-30-2015, 03:19 PM**

(03-30-2015, 02:21 AM)Ryoko Wrote: I have it on good authority that Japanese voice acting is just as much of a clusterfuck as it is in America. You have a handful of good voice actors who dominate the industry because they can do a wide range of voices really well, and everyone else is somewhere between decent and terrible.

This. The thing is western anime fans can't really hear the bad in the Japanese voice acting because most of them can't even identify well known seiyuu - let alone tell different voice actors apart - by voice alone or understand even 10% of what's being said, but believe me it's just as eye rolling and in many cases outright worse than the english.

If you can't understand it you are pretty much incapable of judging if it's actually good or not. It just seems better because you can't tell.

Caspar · **03-30-2015, 03:22 PM**

(03-30-2015, 03:19 PM)allgivenover Wrote:
(03-30-2015, 02:21 AM)Ryoko Wrote: I have it on good authority that Japanese voice acting is just as much of a clusterfuck as it is in America. You have a handful of good voice actors who dominate the industry because they can do a wide range of voices really well, and everyone else is somewhere between decent and terrible.

This. The thing is western anime fans can't really hear the bad in the Japanese voice acting because most of them can't even identify well known seiyuu - let alone tell different voice actors apart - by voice alone or understand even 10% of what's being said, but believe me it's just as eye rolling and in many cases outright worse than the english.

If you can't understand it you are pretty much incapable of judging if it's actually good or not. It just seems better because you can't tell.

It seems to me most of the people who picked sub in this thread understand at least a little Japanese or are used to picking subs.

In my experience, those people who don't know anything about the JP industry or know any seiyuu by name usually pick dubs, and not the other way around.

You should consider also that the standards for what is considered normal voice acting for the industry are different. The JP audience observed that they preferred Bosch to Fukuyama for instance, because they felt his performance wasn't as 'exhausting.' Probably even less of them know how to speak English than there are English anime viewers who understand JP. There are plenty of people who feel similarly with JP performance vs English performance, and I think that's a perfectly valid reason to like it more. If it is "eyerolling" or overdramatic as you say, perhaps that is overacting to some and actually putting effort into your readings for others.

allgivenover · **03-30-2015, 03:33 PM**

(03-30-2015, 03:22 PM)Caspar Wrote: It seems to me most of the people who picked sub in this thread understand at least a little Japanese or are used to picking subs.

Knowing a smattering of nouns/verbs is not the same as being able to hear the difference between å¸°ã‚‹ and å¤‰ãˆã‚‹ or being able to tell if someone is over acting vs phoning the performance in.

kitakaze · **03-30-2015, 03:55 PM**

As someone still learning the language, Â I prefer using JP audio almost exclusively as a sort of study tool. I think that the EN voices have improved, and so have the JP, but it's a good chance to work on my listening comprehension. The subs help with FF related words and as a spot check.Â

That being said, I honestly believe it should be as simple as "I listen to X because I like it."

K'nahli · **03-30-2015, 04:10 PM**

(03-29-2015, 05:11 PM)Edda Wrote: However. Differences in dialogue, however much or little is one thing on its own, and should be expected. Changing a scene, and the complete presentation of a character is another. There is literally no excuse for this. It's not something you can argue either by saying "well, characters like this tend not to exist in Western stuff!" or "it would be hard to localize!" because those are both retarded arguments. Observe.

Haurchefant in English:
[video]

Haurchefant in Japanese:
[video]

No idea what this is like in French or German, though I imagine it's closer to English. I feel bad for the people who watched in English, because they completely missed the presentation of what his character is clearly meant to be. Oh well.

This is precisely what I was talking about. I don't care if the english is the "original" despite my leniency to doubt that much; all it does is reverse my argument in the other direction while maintaining the same point. I will use japanese at the end of the day because whether or not it is simply, terrible voice acting(and I cannot tell the difference), I still find it far more aesthetically pleasing and that could be found equally true to any other language out there for all I know.

However, it all comes back to me wanting the dialogue, ALL dialogue in EVERY language to be as similar as possible so that I am not seeing and hearing a totally different persona from what was intended.

And thank you for that example with Haurchefan, Edda. It illuminated the point I was trying to make much better than the simple and random ones I had presented.

(03-29-2015, 08:28 PM)Caspar Wrote: The real reason why I select JP is that with any foreign-produced media, I generally play or watch it in its original language, or as close to it as I can get. I feel generally the original voice cast is closer to what the production intended for me to experience. Ideally I would be able to listen to it without subtitles but my skill isn't that advanced yet. I do the same for all foreign media.

Absolutely 100% this. Just because I find japanese to be a pleasing language to listen to, it doesn't mean that I would ever consider watching a western production with japanese dubs even if the lip-synching was, somehow, miraculously perfect in spite of the fact.

(03-29-2015, 06:47 PM)Wymsical Wrote:
(03-29-2015, 05:11 PM)Edda Wrote: [Edda talks about Haurchefant here]

Holy crap, I remember getting very confused in the recent MSQ updates when I had on Japanese voices and Haurchefant was being his eccentric self. It was so different from what I knew of him that I thought he was being mind-controlled or had his personality altered. Did a little searching around and turns out... he was always like that in the Japanese version and they just cut that out for the English one (and also apparently his attraction to the player character as well?). It's a pretty jarring difference and I'm disappointed they did it for the sake of apparently keeping Coerthas' story more serious. I'd hope they won't keep doing it but I'm sure Heavensward will be much the same.

This completely surprised me too. The english subtitles suggested that he was very level-headed and considerate in the initial MSQ but then we get that voiced cutscene and his character completely blows that notion out of the water. PLUS, the english dialogue with that episode seemingly caught up with his personality and reflected his more eccentric self this time around.

I mean what? ;;Â Â I don't want your personal adaptions of an intended character please, whether or not that adaption be western or eastern.

(03-30-2015, 03:55 PM)kitakaze Wrote: That being said, I honestly believe it should be as simple as "I listen to X because I like it."

I wish it were, haha. Though once the original personalities or sentences get replaced arbitrarily then I get a bit annoyed. A friend of mine who understands a fair amount of japanese once pointed out to me that Papalymo once said something insulting(in his usual way) to Yda during a cutscene but the english dialogue reflected nothing of the sort. I can't remember what it was exactly, perhaps he was just adding to her point instead while completely taking out the snide side of it(don't quote me on that, but I recall it being quite a bit different).

Cliodhna Eoghan · **03-30-2015, 04:10 PM**

after watching half the main story quest in english...i realized i was able to swap it over to japanese. so i did, no real big reason except i just like how it sounds better. most games i play that have that audio option; i pick japanese.

Zyrusticae · **03-30-2015, 04:19 PM**

(03-30-2015, 03:55 PM)kitakaze Wrote: That being said, I honestly believe it should be as simple as "I listen to X because I like it."

Yup.

When it comes to voice acting I honestly feel this is what it comes down to a lot of the time. The fact that people still cite "bad acting" as a reason to switch from the EN voices tells me that a lot of people don't have a single clue what "bad acting" actually entails, and are just reacting on their gut intuition and trying to explain it after the fact. But to be fair, this goes for a lot of criticism in general - people, especially in the United States, are just not educated enough to articulate their criticism in a useful and constructive fashion. Half the time they're complaining about things using language that is completely off the mark from what they are actually trying to get fixed, or they are attempting to cure symptoms and not the causes, being too short-sighted to understand what really needs to be done (which is one of the most difficult things about games development - people will frequently complain about things without actually being able to articulate how it could get better and why).

Of course, saying "I just don't like it", while accurate, can also make you look dumb or at least inarticulate, so I can understand why folks are reluctant to use it. Criticizing things inaccurately just to avoid that, however, strikes me as even worse in many regards. At least in the former case you're being honest.

Anyway, to answer the thread premise, yes, I prefer the English voices, largely because it just feels the most right to me. I will admit the whole thing with Haurchefaunt gives me pause, but that sort of thing just happens in localization sometimes, and most of the time the localization is simply better for changes made, not worse. I would be curious to hear the story of why Haurchefaunt ended up that way and then getting back to the JP version the next patch. I'm sure deadlines were a part of the reason for that. I have not yet heard a single instance of "bad acting" (and I mean things like someone obviously reading lines from a sheet, or failing to deliver properly, and so on), and am still puzzled every time someone trots out that same line.

Edvyn · **03-30-2015, 04:55 PM**

(03-30-2015, 04:19 PM)Zyrusticae Wrote: When it comes to voice acting I honestly feel this is what it comes down to a lot of the time. The fact that people still cite "bad acting" as a reason to switch from the EN voices tells me that a lot of people don't have a single clue what "bad acting" actually entails, and are just reacting on their gut intuition and trying to explain it after the fact.

~weird paragraph about how this all relates to america and the man and games dev or something~

Of course, saying "I just don't like it", while accurate, can also make you look dumb or at least inarticulate, so I can understand why folks are reluctant to use it. Criticizing things inaccurately just to avoid that, however, strikes me as even worse in many regards. At least in the former case you're being honest.

I have not yet heard a single instance of "bad acting" (and I mean things like someone obviously reading lines from a sheet, or failing to deliver properly, and so on), and am still puzzled every time someone trots out that same line.

bad voice acting = not sounding natural, or not sounding the way they're trying to sound

i doubt anyone's so afraid of sounding dumb or inarticulate or whatever that they'd simply make things up to disguise their peeve with voice acting in a video game (outside the usual minority that need to be acknowledged as internet mensans by complete strangers they will never meet)

in the case of the ffxiv english voice acting, this is actually pretty noticeable if you listen to the accents on some of the characters (minfilia and cid spring to mind). to me, they sound fake as hell. i had this gripe with some of the sylvari voice acting in GW2 as well - it sounds like americans trying to sound like brits. the line delivery/overall tone of voice also feels significantly off, too - which is to say it doesn't follow how people actually talk.

Mod Note - Edited and Merged back into thread at user's request.

Flashhelix · **03-30-2015, 05:00 PM**

I was fine w/ the ENG voices in most other FF games, then I played XIV and Kan-E-Senna's actress sound like she was trying to read lines off a sheet of paper immediately after getting a muay thai beatdown like ryan gosling in Only God Forgives, and Moenbryda's p. subpar too so I've stuck to JP voices

Poll: Your Language Choice for Cutscenes You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
English	63.46%	33	63.46%
Japanese	34.62%	18	34.62%
French	0%	0	0%
German	1.92%	1	1.92%
Total		52 vote(s)	100%

« Next Oldest \| Next Newest »
Pages (5): « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »

Language Preference for Cutscenes

RPC has moved! These pages have been kept for historical purposes