(10-18-2016, 11:08 AM)Aaron Wrote: Lore based consistency is really only as good as the knowledge that your character knows ICly when you think about it.
Disagree.
Roleplay is an activity designed for the enjoyment of a player. If something happens that the player doesn't like, regardless of whether it is known IC or OOC, the activity stops doing what it was designed to do. That would be like saying OOC discomfort should only happen for OOC things, which anyone who has had an unwelcome IC advance would disagree with.
People's ideas of enjoyment do not always mesh, which leads to threads like this one.