It all comes down to plausibility. It's a term more people need to learn to embrace in my opinion since if a character, event or guild can be deemed 'plausible' by multiple role-players who are unaffiliated with each other and not just 'yes men' sucking up to their friends then you can safely consider something to be a success in my eyes.
Meanwhile if people are indulging in critique - constructive or otherwise - and a character, guild or event begins to unravel then that, to me, is a sign that it isn't really all that plausible to begin with.
Something to take into consideration, however, is that some people will nitpick over every last little detail - though in my experience they're few and far between.
Meanwhile if people are indulging in critique - constructive or otherwise - and a character, guild or event begins to unravel then that, to me, is a sign that it isn't really all that plausible to begin with.
Something to take into consideration, however, is that some people will nitpick over every last little detail - though in my experience they're few and far between.
