
Kay, I'm gonna drop some lore links and quoted text that's pertinent then I'll go in to try to answer your questions directly.
So without further ado:
Firstly, the difference lies in the fact that Conjury and Succor are actually two distinctly different forms of magic. While governed by similar rules, Conjury was taught to Mankind by the Moogles of the Twelveswood in order to communicate with the Elementals, and Succor (White Magic) was gifted to Mankind by the Elementals in the time of Amdapor.
Conjurers, through meditation and communion with nature, borrow aether from their immediate environment and mold that aether into a physical manifestation of that nature. This communion with nature is what allows man to hear the Elementals - which are the spirits of nature. White Mages are given access to the Elementals Succor with the intention of healing the world and its denizens, man, animal, and plant. It draws directly from the Lifestream and is focused through the caster.
While it is never expressly stated in what way Succor was abused during the War of the Magi, we can assume that because the War took a great toll on Amdapor, the White Mages of the time period may have been forced to pervert the magic in order to keep up with the unlimited power of the Black Mages.
The Padjal were a race birthed into Man by the Elementals themselves. The children are blessed with the succor, and it eventually alters their bodies as they age. These Padjal children are born Conjurers. It is possible to be a born Conjurer or Hearer and not be a Padjal child, just that Padjali children are born specifically for this purpose. So in a sense, yes, they are stronger.
Succor is the far more effective healing magic, as its sole purpose is to bring healing (succor) to Hydaelyn. Conjury, on the other hand, is not completely a healing magic. It is first and foremost a manipulation of nature - all of her aspects. While design changes made by the Battle Team in 1.20 that carried over into 2.0 have brushed the original lore deep under the rug, the Conjurers originally possessed a mastery over all six elements that composed the Elemental Wheel as described in Essences and Permutations - A Treatise of the Six Elements. Conjurers were capable of incredible destructive feats of elemental sorcery, including Flare, Tornado, Quake, Flood, Freeze, etc.
However, this magic could also be used to heal, not just to destroy. And that's what a majority of Conjurers focused on, but the magic of the Moogles isn't focused on healing like Succor is.
In short, we don't know for sure. There's been some... heated... speculation over the topic, but we're no closer to knowing beyond guesswork. We've known since the very first day of FFXIV Beta in 2010 that Y'shtola was an incredibly accomplished Conjurer. But we know very little about her background, as was made painfully evident by her parting words to Y'mhitra, her estranged sister in Gridania, who is also a Conjurer and student of the lost Allagan Summoning art.
Anyways, I hope this helps! ^^ Lemme know if you have more questions!
So without further ado:
(05-10-2015, 08:41 PM)SayonaraRevival Wrote: 1. how is the practice of conjury different from the practices of succor (whether modern Padjali forms, or the old forms from Amdapor) exactly?
succor was forbidden because it was somehow misused (how, I wonder?) during the War of the Magi... so how is conjury different from white magic in its potential for misuse?
Firstly, the difference lies in the fact that Conjury and Succor are actually two distinctly different forms of magic. While governed by similar rules, Conjury was taught to Mankind by the Moogles of the Twelveswood in order to communicate with the Elementals, and Succor (White Magic) was gifted to Mankind by the Elementals in the time of Amdapor.
Conjurers, through meditation and communion with nature, borrow aether from their immediate environment and mold that aether into a physical manifestation of that nature. This communion with nature is what allows man to hear the Elementals - which are the spirits of nature. White Mages are given access to the Elementals Succor with the intention of healing the world and its denizens, man, animal, and plant. It draws directly from the Lifestream and is focused through the caster.
While it is never expressly stated in what way Succor was abused during the War of the Magi, we can assume that because the War took a great toll on Amdapor, the White Mages of the time period may have been forced to pervert the magic in order to keep up with the unlimited power of the Black Mages.
(05-10-2015, 08:41 PM)SayonaraRevival Wrote: 2. is conjury necessarily "weaker" than white magic?
I'd assume Padjal are generally much 'stronger' than the average Conjurer, and if so, is this because the elementals' gift of white magic, or is it an innate strength of white magic to have stronger healing potential?
The Padjal were a race birthed into Man by the Elementals themselves. The children are blessed with the succor, and it eventually alters their bodies as they age. These Padjal children are born Conjurers. It is possible to be a born Conjurer or Hearer and not be a Padjal child, just that Padjali children are born specifically for this purpose. So in a sense, yes, they are stronger.
Succor is the far more effective healing magic, as its sole purpose is to bring healing (succor) to Hydaelyn. Conjury, on the other hand, is not completely a healing magic. It is first and foremost a manipulation of nature - all of her aspects. While design changes made by the Battle Team in 1.20 that carried over into 2.0 have brushed the original lore deep under the rug, the Conjurers originally possessed a mastery over all six elements that composed the Elemental Wheel as described in Essences and Permutations - A Treatise of the Six Elements. Conjurers were capable of incredible destructive feats of elemental sorcery, including Flare, Tornado, Quake, Flood, Freeze, etc.
However, this magic could also be used to heal, not just to destroy. And that's what a majority of Conjurers focused on, but the magic of the Moogles isn't focused on healing like Succor is.
(05-10-2015, 08:41 PM)SayonaraRevival Wrote: bonus: we see Y'shtola using something that to me resembles Holy in this ... but what is it? some fancy Sharlayan adaptation of Holy? or is it actually something else? does anyone even know the answer to that? is that more the territory of "headcanons"?
In short, we don't know for sure. There's been some... heated... speculation over the topic, but we're no closer to knowing beyond guesswork. We've known since the very first day of FFXIV Beta in 2010 that Y'shtola was an incredibly accomplished Conjurer. But we know very little about her background, as was made painfully evident by her parting words to Y'mhitra, her estranged sister in Gridania, who is also a Conjurer and student of the lost Allagan Summoning art.
Anyways, I hope this helps! ^^ Lemme know if you have more questions!