This has been kind of a complicated point for our LS/FC as well. Â I can just rattle off a bit about what we're doing and maybe it might help you figure out some ideas for your own group, or if you have any questions or I can explain anything any further I'd be glad to clarify.
The history is a bit lengthy and admittedly a little bit off-topic but it still might help, so I'm going to drop it under a spoiler tag:
I've been RPing a lot, both in P3 beta and along various Skype channels in a multitude of settings. Â I wouldn't say so much that Eva's been trying to get from Point A to a concrete Point B. Â Instead I would say we have sort of a direction we're moving in, and certain events and interactions push her in that direction, while others might pull her in a slightly different direction. Â That whole ambiguity thing has been kind of fun for us though.
It sounds like maybe you should discuss the issue with your members in some detail - perhaps explain where you're stuck now and where you'd like to end up and brainstorm some plausible ways to at least move in that general direction. Â Folks who stayed behind may have "forgotten" the faces of those Warriors of Light who disappeared for five years, but you might have some success in trying to jog their memory in-character. Â One good example of this might be a character doesn't believe at first that FriendX is who she says she is. Â After explaining, there is still doubt. Â Then she makes mention of something that only FriendX could have known, and there is a moment of eureka, like that face gets linked back to that character, and its like the one missing puzzle piece fills in all the gaps. Â Or it can be done differently such that a stay-behind character might have to trust that FriendX is telling the truth, and that sort of wariness that may need to be overcome could then become a part of their new relationship, in and of itself. Â There are a lot of really great things you can do with it.
I would love to see an NPC who is like the wife of an NPC Warrior of Light - to see how she might react to her husband's return. Â Or a quest whereby you have to go fetch some items or do some questy things to help him prove to her that he is who he says he is. Â I think that would be really fun, and also sort of cement down the idea that a WoL can sort of return to one of the stay-behind's memory through some sort of deed that proves it. Â But... sadly this is not the case yet, or at least not that I've seen at all. Â Perhaps in ARR we may see something like this or it may be explained to us in greater detail.
Sorry for all my rambling here, but maybe there's some nugget of wisdom that helps? Â I hope... Â
The history is a bit lengthy and admittedly a little bit off-topic but it still might help, so I'm going to drop it under a spoiler tag:
I've been RPing a lot, both in P3 beta and along various Skype channels in a multitude of settings. Â I wouldn't say so much that Eva's been trying to get from Point A to a concrete Point B. Â Instead I would say we have sort of a direction we're moving in, and certain events and interactions push her in that direction, while others might pull her in a slightly different direction. Â That whole ambiguity thing has been kind of fun for us though.
It sounds like maybe you should discuss the issue with your members in some detail - perhaps explain where you're stuck now and where you'd like to end up and brainstorm some plausible ways to at least move in that general direction. Â Folks who stayed behind may have "forgotten" the faces of those Warriors of Light who disappeared for five years, but you might have some success in trying to jog their memory in-character. Â One good example of this might be a character doesn't believe at first that FriendX is who she says she is. Â After explaining, there is still doubt. Â Then she makes mention of something that only FriendX could have known, and there is a moment of eureka, like that face gets linked back to that character, and its like the one missing puzzle piece fills in all the gaps. Â Or it can be done differently such that a stay-behind character might have to trust that FriendX is telling the truth, and that sort of wariness that may need to be overcome could then become a part of their new relationship, in and of itself. Â There are a lot of really great things you can do with it.
I would love to see an NPC who is like the wife of an NPC Warrior of Light - to see how she might react to her husband's return. Â Or a quest whereby you have to go fetch some items or do some questy things to help him prove to her that he is who he says he is. Â I think that would be really fun, and also sort of cement down the idea that a WoL can sort of return to one of the stay-behind's memory through some sort of deed that proves it. Â But... sadly this is not the case yet, or at least not that I've seen at all. Â Perhaps in ARR we may see something like this or it may be explained to us in greater detail.
Sorry for all my rambling here, but maybe there's some nugget of wisdom that helps? Â I hope... Â
"One of the deep secrets of life is that all that is really worth doing is what we do for others." Â ~ Lewis Carol
Eva's Journals  |  Eva's Wiki Page (coming soon)  |  RP Handbook
Eva's Journals  |  Eva's Wiki Page (coming soon)  |  RP Handbook