Sorry to assist in hijacking the thread (partly), but I don't know about keeping rosters here. Once the game starts up, guild leaders are going to have enough to maintain on their own guild websites (rosters, maintenance, etc.), adding a second area for guild rosters here seems redundant and a bit of an unnecessary time-sink.
As far as who moderates the freelancers.. it seems kind of counter-intuitive to have a freelancer "leader".. what happens if that leader settles on which guild they would like to join? There could potentially be a lot of turnover there. Maybe it would be better if freelancers were to adhere to standard forum rules, and be moderated by the forum moderators? If they join in a roleplaying discussion that is guild-specific (ie. something that would need guild-specific rules) that is for whatever reason not on the guild's own website, it seems reasonable that the freelancer would adhere to that guild's roleplaying rules, and not need a moderator of their own.
As far as who moderates the freelancers.. it seems kind of counter-intuitive to have a freelancer "leader".. what happens if that leader settles on which guild they would like to join? There could potentially be a lot of turnover there. Maybe it would be better if freelancers were to adhere to standard forum rules, and be moderated by the forum moderators? If they join in a roleplaying discussion that is guild-specific (ie. something that would need guild-specific rules) that is for whatever reason not on the guild's own website, it seems reasonable that the freelancer would adhere to that guild's roleplaying rules, and not need a moderator of their own.
http://www.tale-ffxiv.com
The Adventure League of Eorzea: A progression & RP guild. FFXIV's longest-running RPLS