TSW is a great game, but it should have gotten higher reviews than it did; it although at first did have the whole "no hand-holding" and I do agree, most of the attack animations suck (as they are changing) and PvP isn't great... but, it's primarily a PvE MMO with PvP as an after-thought. A lot of reviewers were more critical due to "No open world PvP? Uninstall!" I'd give it an 8.5 out of 10 if I was to review it at launch. It's slowly creeping up to 9 with each new update, such as pressing T turns on 'crosshairs mode". Where you don't tab target, but aim at the target and press an ability action!
