I'm a picky little jerk! But I'll try to narrow it down.
Required Voice Chat/Popular Voice Chat. Everyone has kinda covered this one.
Too many people/Too little people.  A small group of maybe 10 people is a bit too tiny for myliking. There’s a comfort in knowing that if someone people need to spend time away the guild isn’t going to die. However, I’d also like not actually know and play with everyone in my guild. I think around 25/30 tops is a pretty ideal size.
Oversexed OOC Chat Either you have no idea what I’m talking about or knowexactly what I’m talking about with this one. Listen, man, I like a good dong joke as much as the next person. I like to objectively discuss sexuality as much as the next person. What I don’t like is feeling as if to be liked/get RP I have to constantly sell my character based on sexual attributes and sexual availability. If the content of chat slowly degrades into “haha and then what (;†. . . Nah, son. I’m done. I’m out.
Hands Off Leadership/Lack of player proactivity There’s nothing inherently wrong with hands off leadership. However,it does mean that the players have to make a concerted effort to stay active. If people aren’t reaching out to one another to RP AND the leaders aren’t doing anything to keep things active then there’s not much reason to stay.
Too Loose of an Application Process If your friend’s RP partner’s sister’s LS mate can getinto the guild on referral alone I’ll probably give the group a hard side eye. As I mostly join RP FCs and the like I think it’s incredibly important that a character and player can fit the general feel of things. Apps are a great way to do this, in my opinion.
It Has A Cool Kids Club I understand that cliques will form anywhere. In fact, Ithink people are really quick to holler IT’S A CLIQUE when they see a group who RP together consistently. I don’t mind that. What I do mind is when they’re given allthe plot and make no effort to involve other people. If there are other players striving to be a part of things then they should get some spotlight, too.
Required Voice Chat/Popular Voice Chat. Everyone has kinda covered this one.
Too many people/Too little people.  A small group of maybe 10 people is a bit too tiny for myliking. There’s a comfort in knowing that if someone people need to spend time away the guild isn’t going to die. However, I’d also like not actually know and play with everyone in my guild. I think around 25/30 tops is a pretty ideal size.
Oversexed OOC Chat Either you have no idea what I’m talking about or knowexactly what I’m talking about with this one. Listen, man, I like a good dong joke as much as the next person. I like to objectively discuss sexuality as much as the next person. What I don’t like is feeling as if to be liked/get RP I have to constantly sell my character based on sexual attributes and sexual availability. If the content of chat slowly degrades into “haha and then what (;†. . . Nah, son. I’m done. I’m out.
Hands Off Leadership/Lack of player proactivity There’s nothing inherently wrong with hands off leadership. However,it does mean that the players have to make a concerted effort to stay active. If people aren’t reaching out to one another to RP AND the leaders aren’t doing anything to keep things active then there’s not much reason to stay.
Too Loose of an Application Process If your friend’s RP partner’s sister’s LS mate can getinto the guild on referral alone I’ll probably give the group a hard side eye. As I mostly join RP FCs and the like I think it’s incredibly important that a character and player can fit the general feel of things. Apps are a great way to do this, in my opinion.
It Has A Cool Kids Club I understand that cliques will form anywhere. In fact, Ithink people are really quick to holler IT’S A CLIQUE when they see a group who RP together consistently. I don’t mind that. What I do mind is when they’re given allthe plot and make no effort to involve other people. If there are other players striving to be a part of things then they should get some spotlight, too.
