obligatory 'inb4' disclaimer:
Okay, here's my feedback! This isn't coming from a bad place, so I apologize in advance if any of my critiques affects you negatively.
I would either rewrite this entire part of her story or scrap it altogether. There's way too many holes that don't make a whole lotta sense. Firstly, why is SHE exempt from the accusation? You say her family, yet the way it's portrayed it's like she isn't a member of said family, since she isn't being punished alongside them. If these accusations are false and just a plot from the Church to root them out, why wouldn't they just execute the entire family and be done with it (or better yet, just banish the outlanders from the city)? Why not have Luna up there on the gallows as well if they're just going to accuse her immediately afterwards?
Another thing about this is, if this was their plan then Luna should've been in custody. The Church is being portrayed as grossly incompetent in this story.
I really don't think that Gridania of all places would lug a potentially voidsent outsider (of a foreign race they'd never seen before) to their city to nurse back to health. The Elementals, I fear, would have a huge problem with that.
Also I'd like to point out that depending on your character's timeline and age, Kan-E-Senna wasn't always the Elder Seedseer. Back in 1.0, Brother E-Sumi was pretty much the HPIC (Head Padjal in Charge). Kan-E and her siblings, like most other Padjal, lived out in the wood with very scarce contact with others. I believe that was around 5-6 years ago from our current events.
If you ever played the THM storyline, one of the Coco brothers gets possessed by a voidsent and they were fully prepared to kill him if they couldn't exorcise the demon. It's a morbid reality but that's how it goes.
It makes absolutely no sense that Luna's parents would have a soul crystal for white magic, and that Seedseers would just allow a void-touched stranger to keep it. White Magic is so INSANELY unique and gifted upon Padjals by the Elementals. There is absolutely no way the Elementals would bestow succor to a void-touched outlander.
Roleplaying a white mage under any circumstances is considered a bit taboo in the community, just due to how special and unique they are.
I jest I jest!
Ok, in closing this is what I'd do.
- If insistent on Ishgard backstory, elaborate on past and cover up holes for plausibility.
- Completely get rid of the voidsent plotline. Change 'Lu'Ventras' into a chocobo or something.
- Pay closer attention to her timeline. Remember, Eorzea isn't stagnant. A lot of things occur over the course of several years.
- Humble her abilities. She should have one specialty that stems from the base classes. Conjurer, Lancer, Arcanist, etc.
- Get rid of the important NPC's in Luna's story. Replace them with OC's.
- Change her birth name into something that sounds more Raen-ish. 'Lu'naha Aeg'Celes' doesn't sound like it follows the Raen naming conventions. I could be wrong though(?)
I also suggest consulting with Sounsyy for help with better lore compliance! She helped me out a long time ago with several questions I had.
Okay, here's my feedback! This isn't coming from a bad place, so I apologize in advance if any of my critiques affects you negatively.
Quote:She claims Ishgard as her birthplace since that is where she made her first memories. "Some hole in the Brume" she would say with a slight frown tugging athe her lips. Her father had rescued the son of a nobleman and was begrudgingly granted asylum.I'm not well-versed in Au Ra lore so I could be wrong about this, but iirc the Raen Clan are closely related to Doma over in Othard. Now, I'm not saying that her family can't have immigrated to the Holy See, but I do think you should explain how and why her family is seeking asylum. It's a long ways from home.
Quote:Regardless of her father's deed, she was spat on every day. "Dravanian trash! Scaled whore!" They would yell at her as they threw stones. Her mother and father received death threats daily, her brother came home with bruises, almost constantly.Again, this warrants a more thorough backstory because as I'm reading this I'm wondering why the father would retire his family to such a place. They're being spat on, emotionally / verbally / physically abused, and their lives are being threatened on a daily basis. How dire is their situation that they find themselves completely stuck in Ishgard? Why choose to stay?
Quote:One day the knights came and accused her family of heresy and would stand trial to answer for their crimes. The knights took her family and put them on trial, finding them guilty and sentencing them to death. Lu'Naha watched as her family was hanged, A group of knights had cornered her after the execution and said it was her turn to pay for her sins.
I would either rewrite this entire part of her story or scrap it altogether. There's way too many holes that don't make a whole lotta sense. Firstly, why is SHE exempt from the accusation? You say her family, yet the way it's portrayed it's like she isn't a member of said family, since she isn't being punished alongside them. If these accusations are false and just a plot from the Church to root them out, why wouldn't they just execute the entire family and be done with it (or better yet, just banish the outlanders from the city)? Why not have Luna up there on the gallows as well if they're just going to accuse her immediately afterwards?
Another thing about this is, if this was their plan then Luna should've been in custody. The Church is being portrayed as grossly incompetent in this story.
Quote: she ran with them in close pursuit. She fled across the Steps of Faith and into the snow, never looking back.Again, she should've been in custody if this was their plan. She shouldn't of been able to escape. Ishgard is heavily gated and fortified. This isn't plausible. Also, Coerthas hasn't always been a snowy wasteland, so there might be some issues with her timeline.
Quote:The VoidCompletely of my opinion, but many people who go the Void-touched route go into it with a gross underestimation of the effects of possession. Being tempered by voidsent is, ICly, very very serious and should be treated as such. NPCs and the like won't want you anywhere near their cities, especially an isolated and oft time xenophobic place like Gridania. In 1.0, the slightest touch of woodsin alone was enough to get the city up and arms about your being there.
I really don't think that Gridania of all places would lug a potentially voidsent outsider (of a foreign race they'd never seen before) to their city to nurse back to health. The Elementals, I fear, would have a huge problem with that.
Quote:He says she was brought before the Elder Seedseer and the voidsent was to be expelled.I'd personally refrain from using NPCs of importance in your backstory, it's a bit of a turnoff to some.
Also I'd like to point out that depending on your character's timeline and age, Kan-E-Senna wasn't always the Elder Seedseer. Back in 1.0, Brother E-Sumi was pretty much the HPIC (Head Padjal in Charge). Kan-E and her siblings, like most other Padjal, lived out in the wood with very scarce contact with others. I believe that was around 5-6 years ago from our current events.
Quote:succubus and her host were now bonded, one needing the other to survive. Luna went to see the Elder Seedseer. *She met Y'mhithra. She was told that the necklace given to her by her mother, and the wristlet by her father, were in fact soul crystals of the White Mage and Summoner respectively. Should she accept, Luna would be taught to become a White Mage or Summoner. Luna said yes.Again, it's hard for me to imagine that Gridania would harbor a voidsent in spite of the elementals and not just outright kill Luna after failing to purge the succubus.
If you ever played the THM storyline, one of the Coco brothers gets possessed by a voidsent and they were fully prepared to kill him if they couldn't exorcise the demon. It's a morbid reality but that's how it goes.
It makes absolutely no sense that Luna's parents would have a soul crystal for white magic, and that Seedseers would just allow a void-touched stranger to keep it. White Magic is so INSANELY unique and gifted upon Padjals by the Elementals. There is absolutely no way the Elementals would bestow succor to a void-touched outlander.
Roleplaying a white mage under any circumstances is considered a bit taboo in the community, just due to how special and unique they are.
Quote:Luna had matured into a fine young Raen. lessons with the Miqo'te. Her time with the Padjal had taught her powerful healing spells and potent offensive magic. Darmen had become a father figure to her and Kan-E-Senna a mother.Again, I'd like to re-emphasize that utilizing important NPCs in your backstory so intimately will be a turn off to many. Y'mhitra's apprentice? Kan-E-Stepmommy? Noooooooooooooope.
Quote:She had learned to live with the succubus within her, although she couldn't completely repress her. In times of great exhaustion, lack of aether, or emotional breaks, the succubus could assume control. she could be very flirtatious and even promiscuous, leaving and returning on the arm of traveling merchantIIRC Voidsent are only concerned with consuming as much aether as they can. They thrive on aether. So unless Luna is low-key eating these merchants, I don't think the control lapses should exist unless you really plan on showcasing the dread of a voidsent takeover. She should be at the center of Tam-Tara Deepcroft with the flying head of her fiance.
Quote:She packed her bag and her grimoire, took up her staff and lance,To briefly come back to this point: There's no shame in humbling her abilities. The meta-game allows us multiple classes on a single character, but realistically mastering or even becoming competent in just one would take many years of practice. Her being a summoner / white mage / lancer is WAY too much. She either should be an arcanist, conjurer, or lancer.
Quote:Soon her past had come back to haunt her. brought forth all the memories and emotions Luna had locked away. Unprepared for the assault, Luna quickly succumbed to rage and hatredCRAAAAWLING IN MY SKIIIIN.
I jest I jest!
Ok, in closing this is what I'd do.
- If insistent on Ishgard backstory, elaborate on past and cover up holes for plausibility.
- Completely get rid of the voidsent plotline. Change 'Lu'Ventras' into a chocobo or something.
- Pay closer attention to her timeline. Remember, Eorzea isn't stagnant. A lot of things occur over the course of several years.
- Humble her abilities. She should have one specialty that stems from the base classes. Conjurer, Lancer, Arcanist, etc.
- Get rid of the important NPC's in Luna's story. Replace them with OC's.
- Change her birth name into something that sounds more Raen-ish. 'Lu'naha Aeg'Celes' doesn't sound like it follows the Raen naming conventions. I could be wrong though(?)
I also suggest consulting with Sounsyy for help with better lore compliance! She helped me out a long time ago with several questions I had.
![[Image: tumblr_olm3wtIVmQ1w2go25o1_250.png]](https://68.media.tumblr.com/54ccdf85031f98288069dcc3326c6567/tumblr_olm3wtIVmQ1w2go25o1_250.png)
