+- Hydaelyn Role-Players (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18)
+-- Forum: Final Fantasy 14 (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18/forumdisplay.php?fid=41)
+--- Forum: FFXIV Discussion (https://ffxiv-roleplayers.com/mybb18/forumdisplay.php?fid=12)
+--- Thread: This idea needs our support RPC (/showthread.php?tid=11062)
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - Temmi - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 02:09 PM)Lililove Wrote: If people aren't fond of the idea, that's all well and good. But posting on here just to say you won't support it when the OP is simply trying to promote what he sees as a good idea seems kind of...I don't know...meh? If you don't like it and don't want to support it, then go about your business. No need to make this all into something negative.
I believe, madam, that you misinterpret (at least in my case). I was not trying to make anything negative at all. I merely stated my opinion on this topic without criticism, harshness, or condescension, then presented a (in my opinion) much more workable idea to open up some brainstorming/discussion. I get the same impression from everyone who's posted something against the idea.
This is a forum, and people are going to discuss things that are posted. If it's not meant to be discussed, and it was only meant to be a PSA, then why would anyone respond, positive or negative?
EDIT: I think.. we should speak when we don't like something. Changes like these effect everyone, not just those who do like the idea. If people politely explain their distaste for something (which... every single person who has posted opposition so far has...(seriously, I've never seen more polite disagreement on a public forum ever)) it can only lead to a better understanding of what people desire.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - Wymsical - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 01:59 PM)Erik Mynhier Wrote: I found the quest rewarded unique gear and emotes to be a fresh idea.
We technically have that already! There could be more specific ones, true. I'm curious if you mean emotes and gear that are meant for very particular 'roles', possibly limiting players to which one they can pick? That would be the real significance in such a system, not letting everyone take each quest and rewards. That'd probably work better in a game that doesn't promote doing everything on one character; in FFXIV this means everyone would have all of the vampire, werewolf, dancer and ect abilities simply because the game has a 'gotta catch 'em all' design.
I think the real downfall of the link you posted is the focus on supernatural abilities instead XIV-centric things. Therefore, promoting it might imply an interest in that instead of the mechanic (which already exists in a more minor, less focused form).
(04-12-2015, 02:35 PM)Temariah Wrote: This is a forum, and people are going to discuss things that are posted. If it's not meant to be discussed, and it was only meant to be a PSA, then why would anyone respond, positive or negative?
This exactly; feedback is all I (and presumably the others) meant.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - K'nahli - 04-12-2015
Despite the abundance of replies indicating that they are not feeling supportive of all of the post's content, I can't really say that I got a negative impression from them.
Erik referenced the topic. Some liked it, some only liked parts, most discussed it and ideas & thoughts flowed.
Having said that, if I gave off such an impression then I am really sorry. The poster did put a lot of thought and work into it and they deserve recognition for that. I was just sharing my opinion that the concept is not wholly to my tastes.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - Spiritual Machine - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 01:59 PM)Erik Mynhier Wrote: I really wasn't focusing so much on the vampire thing as everyone else. I found the quest rewarded unique gear and emotes to be a fresh idea. And I was really impressed by the level of detail the idea-maker put into it.Well you did say that it needed the RPC's support...
Sure some of it wasn't great but she got my support as she had a good idea that could be refined by the developers into something workable. That was why I asked to up her post. So the DEVs would see it and maybe implement some of the better parts of the idea is all. You are of course not obligated to support her. I am sorry if you all took it that way.
I'm willing to bet the actual reason people aren't jumping on this is because it's a solid, specific idea for a new in-game system, and its format and function aren't appealing to them.
In my opinion, the idea is just superfluous--we already have quests and updates that introduce bonus outfits and emotes and such. I imagine most people just want more of that stuff. It's like how if you supported reform to combat global warming, you wouldn't just throw your support behind a costly and ridiculous proposal to build a heat-destroying Doomsday Weapon. There are probably better ways to raise awareness about an issue you're passionate about than by blowing up the sun with a Death Ray.
Though I guess that would get people's attention.
Anyway, I feel like if folks want the good elements and ideas in this to be upped and considered, then a thread with general pro-roleplay ideas should be promoted and discussed on the main forum.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - Aris - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 02:35 PM)Temariah Wrote:(04-12-2015, 02:09 PM)Lililove Wrote: If people aren't fond of the idea, that's all well and good. But posting on here just to say you won't support it when the OP is simply trying to promote what he sees as a good idea seems kind of...I don't know...meh? If you don't like it and don't want to support it, then go about your business. No need to make this all into something negative.
<post>
I agree completely. Definitely not trying to be negative! Erik invited us to talk about the idea and we are. It's interesting to hear everyone's views as how SE can advance roleplaying further, and bounce off more ideas.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - Cato - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 04:35 AM)ArmachiA Wrote: As a huge V:TM fan I say this with the most love:
No vampires please.
Mm. I love them too but they're very rarely pulled off well and they're usually just a recipe for drama in the role-playing community. The bulk of vampires end up being conveniently attractive, super strong, charming and without any real drawbacks. Most aren't even subtle about what they are even if realistically they'd be hunted down the moment they admitted to being a creature of the night that preys upon innocents.
The base idea of more cosmetic stuff isn't terrible, mind you, but I'd rather just see more emotes and gear added through quests, The Gold Saucer and as rewards for various in-game activities.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - Warren Castille - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 07:45 PM)Graeham Ridgefield Wrote: The bulk of _______ end up being conveniently attractive, super strong, charming and without any real drawbacks.
Apply as needed when discussing RP characters.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - allgivenover - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 02:09 PM)Lililove Wrote: My family is big into MMOs like my sister and stepdad and my sister especially is one of those who loves goofy shit like this. It reminds me of some of the items they implemented in GW2 like the bobblehead factory and the random boxes that can turn you into a giant or into a mini or into a stuffed gryphon.
I'll pray to the Twelve that our goofy stuff remains the way it is and doesn't dip into this territory.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - Marisa - 04-12-2015
I'll give all the moral support I can, but I'm still perma-banned from the official forums.
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - K'nahli - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 07:50 PM)Warren Castille Wrote:(04-12-2015, 07:45 PM)Graeham Ridgefield Wrote: The bulk of _______ end up being conveniently attractive, super strong, charming and without any real drawbacks.
Apply as needed when discussing RP characters.
Shut the hell up!
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - Warren Castille - 04-12-2015
(04-12-2015, 09:16 PM)Knahli Wrote:(04-12-2015, 07:50 PM)Warren Castille Wrote:(04-12-2015, 07:45 PM)Graeham Ridgefield Wrote: The bulk of _______ end up being conveniently attractive, super strong, charming and without any real drawbacks.
Apply as needed when discussing RP characters.
Shut the hell up!
RE: This idea needs our support RPC - allgivenover - 04-12-2015
Moderator brutality! Moderator brutality! You all saw it!
Silliness aside, my reasons for not supporting the idea has nothing to do with the vampire/demon class.
The truth is despite there being a push for official support of RPers in the form of an "RP" tag for certain servers or more extreme stuff like this idea, after nearly fifteen years of MMO roleplaying I am not convinced that official tools or mechanics designed to "support" roleplay do anything of the sort, in fact I think even minimal recognition like RP tags for official RP servers is completely unnecessary, does nothing to support roleplay, and in some ways is detrimental.
The only idea I've ever liked is the one that SE currently employs in XIV, allowing individual groups to mark themselves as roleplayers, the way we can mark our FCs as "role play" now.
We don't need anything more than that.