I think I'd take the good tank, someone who can a) hold aggro!, b) play their class and know how to manage cooldowns etc to help out the "bad healer", c) know the dungeons/encounters and be able to lead their groups accordingly. I main a Monk but I also play 50 Warrior and 50 Scholar so it's pretty easy to see that every role has something that they have to bring to the table. It's probably one of the things I like the most about this game: while it's definitely possible to carry folks through some content, there's plenty others where everyone has to be on the ball or else things probably aren't going to go well.
![[Image: d_footer.png]](http://cuideag.com/ffxiv/resources/d_footer.png)
