Hydaelyn Role-Players

Sorry if this has come up before, I'm very new to this site. Let me just start out by saying that I roleplay Minfilia and have been wanting to have some fun storylines with other people on my server, who're pretty much a mixed big at the moment with some people rather interested and others who can't help but troll due to my character of choice. 

My current plan of action for setting a scene is having Minfilia take a break from her duties and travelling through Ul'dah. A friend of mine even made a Tataru so we could go "shopping" together through the bazaar. Generally though, a lot of the attitudes I get from people are actually more negative than positive, with some people refusing to acknowledge the idea that Minfilia is present due to spoilers later in the game.

If there are any other NPC roleplayers out there, have you encountered this before and how did you tackle the situation if so? The easiest solution would be to just ignore these people and move on but being on an EU server where finding other roleplayers is already quite challenging, I'd rather not give up on people unless I absolutely had to.

I don't roleplay as an NPC but the conversation has come up a bit here before. It's a divisive topic (as you're already away) and I think I get some of the insight into it. Mix and match from the following as needed:

1) Most people doing it tend to shoehorn in their fan-canon personalities. Since only the official writing team knows how NPCs would react at various instances, the best any player can do is an educated guess at best. Some people do it pretty well, but there's also those who are just in it for the attention. Haurchefant got several people roleplaying him on Balmung, as did the Heaven's Ward.

2) The spoilers you referred to. Tataru and Minf doing some light shopping is impossible according to the lore.

3) Connections. NPCs come with a level of renown: Yours, for example, works with the most powerful adventurer on the planet and is respected by more-or-less every single important country leader that we know of. It's the political equivalent of Superman just throwing all of his problems into the sun. This has an odd extension when it comes to other players, though, since anyone who you would become friends with would technically have you to call upon should they have need.

This is pretty easily remedied by being unavailable or keeping these sorts of excursions limited to your group of friends; I'm speaking for the more broad archetypes where people are roleplaying in bars and pubs and actively LOOKING to make connections. These things are impossible to utilize while staying in the rough boundaries of the canon.

There's nothing wrong with using NPCs in your own stories, but if you're trying to mesh into open-world roleplay it can get tricky. What happens if someone else decides they want to play your character? Any connections you've made don't necessarily exist for that person, so it splinters any sort of coherency you've established.

(02-06-2017, 10:45 PM)Warren Castille Wrote: [ -> ]I don't roleplay as an NPC but the conversation has come up a bit here before. It's a divisive topic (as you're already away) and I think I get some of the insight into it. Mix and match from the following as needed:

1) Most people doing it tend to shoehorn in their fan-canon personalities. Since only the official writing team knows how NPCs would react at various instances, the best any player can do is an educated guess at best. Some people do it pretty well, but there's also those who are just in it for the attention. Haurchefant got several people roleplaying him on Balmung, as did the Heaven's Ward.

2) The spoilers you referred to. Tataru and Minf doing some light shopping is impossible according to the lore.

3) Connections. NPCs come with a level of renown: Yours, for example, works with the most powerful adventurer on the planet and is respected by more-or-less every single important country leader that we know of. It's the political equivalent of Superman just throwing all of his problems into the sun. This has an odd extension when it comes to other players, though, since anyone who you would become friends with would technically have you to call upon should they have need.

This is pretty easily remedied by being unavailable or keeping these sorts of excursions limited to your group of friends; I'm speaking for the more broad archetypes where people are roleplaying in bars and pubs and actively LOOKING to make connections. These things are impossible to utilize while staying in the rough boundaries of the canon.

There's nothing wrong with using NPCs in your own stories, but if you're trying to mesh into open-world roleplay it can get tricky. What happens if someone else decides they want to play your character? Any connections you've made don't necessarily exist for that person, so it splinters any sort of coherency you've established.

I get what you're saying, but when it comes to timelines or characters being affected by plotpoints, couldn't we just attribute the entire situation to a case of willing suspension of disbelief? I'm not sure why some people take things to be so literal as that same kind of logic could be used elsewhere and become very restrictive. Saying that though, I come from a rather casual RP background so I might just be a bit more liberal?

EDIT: Wonderful points, by the way. Thank you very much for commenting.

(02-06-2017, 11:14 PM)Opto Mistique Wrote: [ -> ]I get what you're saying, but when it comes to timelines or characters being affected by plotpoints, couldn't we just attribute the entire situation to a case of willing suspension of disbelief? I'm not sure why some people take things to be so literal as that same kind of logic could be used elsewhere and become very restrictive. Saying that though, I come from a rather casual RP background so I might just be a bit more liberal?

EDIT: Wonderful points, by the way. Thank you very much for commenting.

It's...

It breaks immersion so, so much to have someone RPing as an NPC. It's one thing if you were a person running the story, but expecting everyone else to play along with you is just kinda...

I think you're right, OP, in that it's a difference in what kind of community you're coming from?

I know the kind of environment you're talking about, if it's anything like the tumblr RP blog scene was when I partook - where it's about pursuing "what ifs" and throwing your character into all sorts of weird and wonderful situations to see how they react. In that kind of environment, RPing with a canon is an enjoyable exercise in what happens when an OC meets a famous person, or an idol, etc etc. There's a wide acceptance that different AU's/verses are a thing, so if you meet duplicates it's NBD. And it's acceptable to state that you're exclusive with one particular instance of the canon, too.

But the kind of situation most in-game RPers are in is one where they're roleplaying one character as part of a larger living world, with usually a fairly strict continuity - because communicating details of retcons across everyone who might possibly have seen the scene in question is usually a pain. They stick to "everything that happens, happens for real, and retcons/AUs are a special exception". In this kind of environment, encountering a canon in the open world is a huge "not even touching that", for all the reasons Warren described. There's no way to communicate the nature of different AU's to the entire audience unless the RP is held privately from start to finish, and there's no way to communicate if you're exclusive with an existing RPer for that canon short of whispering the one that just walked up to you and saying "sorry, no can do".

And because most people are RPing regular folk... RPing a canon, or being friends with one, comes with a certain level of political clout that just is not available to others. It has the potential to stray into power-emoting territory in some respects, which I think is why people are wary of it. It also has the potential to tie IC political power into who is and isn't friends with the canon RPer OOCly - who only has that clout because they picked a canon character to play... rather than establishing it the long way around, with genuinely building an IC reputation for themself.

I used to play canon characters on my RP blogs, and I have a few clones of canons on other servers, but... I kinda draw the line at RPing them in-game, especially walk-up style. It's just too at odds with the established culture, and with the type of clashes that can breed resentment.

(02-06-2017, 11:14 PM)Opto Mistique Wrote: [ -> ]I get what you're saying, but when it comes to timelines or characters being affected by plotpoints, couldn't we just attribute the entire situation to a case of willing suspension of disbelief? I'm not sure why some people take things to be so literal as that same kind of logic could be used elsewhere and become very restrictive. Saying that though, I come from a rather casual RP background so I might just be a bit more liberal?

EDIT: Wonderful points, by the way. Thank you very much for commenting.

No worries, I get where you're coming from.

There's definitely a space for suspension of disbelief. That's sort of required on some level to roleplay in the first place, after all.

Hell, in a random one-off where the episode title is "Minfy and Tataru Shop for Shoes" there's no need to worry about any of the things I mentioned. One-offs aren't as-common on RP servers, though: Most of the people here have existed for weeks and months and years. Some of the people here have been roleplaying since the 1.0 release in 2010(!).

RP as a hobby brings people from all sorts of motivations and rationales. The biggest challenge is that as soon as you do something that incorporates random people is that all of those philosophies are thrown into a blender: The one-offs and the hard-lore people and the light-fun people all end up dropped into the same place. I wasn't trying to talk you into or out of anything, though! I just wanted to explain why some people are so resistant.

It's most-often a case of "You are too important to hang out with us, this would fuck up the Main Story if it happened and that's the law of the land" sort of things.

You are indeed right as this has been brought up a few times in the past. Here's a link to at least two of the threads I know of off-hand.

Thread 1
Thread 2

As for RP'ing a canon character... It's not my favorite thing to say the least. Not that I haven't met three Hildibrand RP'ers, and at least one full set of the scions, and the Sultana herself walking about unguarded as if saying she was Sultana in public was... A wise thing?

Not my cup of tea, personally.


As for the 'spoilers' you mentioned prior. A lot of the RP'ers have been RP'ing since 2.0 (or back in 1.0) so the continuity of the story gets broken if suddenly, Minifilia appears. The moment you hit 3.0, what Minfilia? I'm sure you can see why people would avoid such a situation, especially when said character isn't about when they, themselves, are RP'ing HW content.

(02-07-2017, 12:02 AM)Nodem Wrote: [ -> ]It's not my favorite thing to say the least. Not that I haven't met three Hildibrand RP'ers, and at least one full set of the scions, and the Sultana herself walking about unguarded as if saying she was Sultana in public was... A wise thing?

"Anyone who kills their opponent will have their head removed from their shoulders and be dumped in the wash."

"They'll WHAT?"

I didn't mind the Sultana crashing the Grindstone, mostly because 1) Warren was one of the guards at the original Sultana Ball some years ago and 2) she didn't try to stop us.

You'd be surprised at how many times "I've got an army of <Grand Company Soldiers> waiting" has been invoked in roleplay.

Yooo, Grindstone plug in a random thread. I'VE STILL GOT IT.

I'll keep all of this in mind, then. Thank you for all your thoughts. For now, I think I'll just focus on my OC and see if I can root myself down somewhere.

I think NPC RPers are cool~ It's fun to RP with them.

I was running an event at a tavern I co own - the Lominsan Star. And the Sultana showed up. I thought it was fun, and she was under the guise of Lady Lilira. The disguise she has on during the Thanalan starter quests? So my character just played dumb and served her drinks. I think one guy was able to figure out who she was because he was a Sultansworn but otherwise she came in with everyone else not suspecting she was the Sultana. That was the only time I encountered a NPC roleplayer. 

I don't really care, I think you should RP what makes you happy and if my character gets approached by one, they'll just either play dumb or be in disbelief, depending on the situation.

I treat NPC role-play as one of two things:

1. They are just clowning around and joking, so I treat them like I would treat them a costumed star at Disney World. "Oh hey! Its Mickey Mouse! Let me shake your hand and get a picture." and my character goes on their merry way, laughing it off.

2. If they are trying to SERIOUSLY RP as that character? My character will treat them as someone delusional, touched in the head or drunk. Because thats the only way it would make sense.

(02-07-2017, 09:01 AM)Tyndles Wrote: [ -> ]2.  If they are trying to SERIOUSLY RP as that character?  My character will treat them as someone delusional, touched in the head or drunk.  Because thats the only way it would make sense.

I keep seeing people post this in every thread this is brought up. I find this reaction to be mean spirited and contemptuous. And it doesn't seem to be in the spirit of role play. It's weird where people draw the line between "okay, I'll pretend your character is/has this, but if you say they are/have this I'm going to be derisive and try to make you feel bad.

I think, ultimately, one of the key aspects of roleplaying comes out stronger in this situation than any other - communication.

It's a vital key for any RP, but it seems all the more important when you're bringing in an existing character and trying to play as them. Think about it, even with your personal character, you usually want to make sure that whoever you're RPing with is okay with rolling with whatever you're putting down - whether it's that your character is a minor merchant, a noble of some note, or a master of black and white magic, to go down a "line" of suspension. If you look at it in the abstract, saying you're playing the Sultana or one of the Scions or what-have-you is kind of along that same premise.

The only issue is, I suppose, for generic walk-up RP... but even then there's a sort of similar connection. Many folks pick at and poke fun at the half-voidsent and the manifested primals and other odd character ideas that are apparently taking a break from whatever realm-shaking things they're doing to just sit in the Quicksand and have a beer. Seems kind of similar to how someone would react to the Sultana coming in for one as well, no? It's a matter of imposing something in a public setting that may be "forcing" you to accept something into your character's "canon" that you may not like or want. So you ignore it entirely or write it off as someone being a bit touched in the head.

Which is why it comes back to communication. Playing such an idea - whether it be some great demon or Minfilia - works better in an enclosed environment because you can ensure that all those participating are on board and willing to accept that concept. It's just harder to do that in open-world RP because there's just so many folks around - especially on Balmung - that the chance someone or someones is going to have an issue with it arises, and that they feel they're being "forced" to accept it because it's occurring right out in the open. And so ire arises.

Ultimately, and it's sort of the lackluster fallback statement of the RPC at this point, "you can play whatever you want, people just may not like it." So, if you're playing something you're not sure most people are going to jive with... I'd recommend just asking them first. And if you're doing a scene out in the open, maybe keep the RP in party chat so that those open-world RPers don't feel like they're being "forced" to accept the fact that the Sultana had a little bit too much to drink and needs someone to hold her hair back over the planter in the corner. That way you can have your RP, they can have their RP, and no one really feels like one's imposing on the other.

... Oddly enough, I suppose it's kinda like ERP. You know it's happening, but people don't seem to mind it too much because it's all being kept to party chat and tells.

(02-07-2017, 09:29 AM)Aegir Wrote: [ -> ]

(02-07-2017, 09:01 AM)Tyndles Wrote: [ -> ]2.  If they are trying to SERIOUSLY RP as that character?  My character will treat them as someone delusional, touched in the head or drunk.  Because thats the only way it would make sense.

I keep seeing people post this in every thread this is brought up. I find this reaction to be mean spirited and contemptuous. And it doesn't seem to be in the spirit of role play. It's weird where people draw the line between "okay, I'll pretend your character is/has this, but if you say they are/have this I'm going to be derisive and try to make you feel bad.

Welllll not to play devil's advocate here, but I assume people don't come in here just for praise and people, like myself for example, will avoid them at any cost, and we are forced to use that IC to still let it make sense.

Because I really don't want my characters to know (certain) NPCs, because it really shatters my immersion.

There's quite a bit of NPC roleplayers who shove their RP down your throat and start screaming if you don't accept it. Everyone's allowed to go 'no' on whatever type RP. Whether it is just casual tavern RP, super serious events, ERP, or RPing with NPCs; if people don't want to, they should be allowed to step out as well.

And really, I think that excuse of "its a drunkard/weirdo trying to re-enact x character' isn't really that bad. I don't even bother with it, unless they engaged me directly. I just u-turn, or ask them to leave.