Who is the best Songbird and why is it Masha?

[111]

Discussion on why Masha is the best songbird, and why the other two are pieces of trash.

[Momo]

It happens once in a blue moon that I am to choose anything other than the Lalafell choice, but I absolutely agree.  Sometimes trash is good, this time not so much, there is but one true Songbird, that is Masha, most beautiful and genuine of the group, a clear winner over the Karen and Regina George's of the world.

[Gegenji]

I've never really got into the whole idol thing but... I think all three of them have their strengths?

 

Ulala, for one, has (or at least presents) that confidence and go-get-'em attitude that is both very Lalafellan and likely to help push the group towards their goals as their leader. After all, the other two were approached for their talent, Ulala went hunting the guy down to say "HEY, PICK ME." Gotta respect that, even if her ego can be abrasive and her push to succeed overbearing.

 

Masha is, from what I can tell, an actual musical talent. She was actively hunted down, likes singing and dancing - and is actively trying to improve on both. It's no wonder a lot of folks are rooting for her. To add a negative point like for Ulala - which I will try to keep in pattern - she also seems the one starting most of the fights between the three of them and could be the drama queen.

 

Narumi is the timid one, which could be a bit of a detraction because she seems to have little self-confidence and could easily be walked over. However, she was also sought out like Masha, and seems to have an earnest love of singing and the like. Also she is usually the one trying to calm the other two down - when they're "at each other's throats" it's Ulala and Masha clashing with her trying to mediate, albeit poorly.

 

So, I think there's things to like in all of them. However, the quest is to pick a "leader." So it'd have to be someone who would push the group towards the goal. Which, unless Narumi's shyness and timid approach can be overcome, she's ill-suited for. So, that puts it between Masha and Ulala - and I worry Masha's open causing of conflict would theoretically cause more problems than Ulala's ego.

 

As such, I will vote for the popoto.

[111]

 

As such, I will vote for the popoto.

Ugh, you would.

[Virella]

Tbh the Lalafell has too much of an ego

 

Au ra are just trash NPC and PCs both 99% of the time, this one being no different

 

So that leaves catte girl

 

SE y u no include stronk roe or highlander woman > : (

[111]

Tbh the Lalafell has too much of an ego

 

Au ra are just trash NPC and PCs both 99% of the time, this one being no different

 

So that leaves catte girl

 

SE y u no include stronk roe or highlander woman > : (

Well, they're described as prepubescent. So they're supposed to be little cutesy idol girls.

 

Seeing a child roe would be funny though.

[Gegenji]

 

As such, I will vote for the popoto.

Ugh, you would.

 

If it helps, I don't care enough to do that repeatable quest 20 times to cement my vote as "really important" or whatever. I just did it three times - two for clogs, one for the vote.

[111]

 

As such, I will vote for the popoto.

Ugh, you would.

 

If it helps, I don't care enough to do that repeatable quest 20 times to cement my vote as "really important" or whatever. I just did it three times - two for clogs, one for the vote.

I DO.